Runbooks vs Playbooks: A Guide to Understanding Operational Documentation

Ever find yourself worried about forgetting the intricate details of how your team resolved a recent incident? You’re not alone. This is where crucial operational documentation like runbooks and playbooks come into play.

Runbooks and playbooks serve as the cornerstones of organizational knowledge, providing essential information and instructions for teams to navigate tasks and processes effectively. They not only empower your team to be self-sufficient but also free up valuable time for your ever-growing to-do list. While teams might use the terms “runbook and playbook” interchangeably, it’s important to understand the key distinctions between these two types of documentation.

What are Runbooks?

Runbooks function as operational guides, outlining step-by-step procedures for various scenarios. They act as essential resources for operational teams, ensuring consistency and efficiency in carrying out routine tasks, troubleshooting, and incident resolution. These documents are straightforward, presenting a series of steps for manual execution, full automation, or a combination of both by your team.

Typically integrated into a playbook, runbooks serve specific purposes within broader processes. Similar to playbooks, runbooks prove beneficial for both routine and crisis-related situations.

When to Use Runbooks

• Incident Response: Runbooks guide teams through predefined steps to address and mitigate incidents.
• Routine System Maintenance: Ensure teams follow a consistent and efficient process when performing updates, patches, or system checks.
• Server Management: Automate tasks such as creating a new server instance, installing web application software, configuring application settings, and deploying the application to production.
• Data Management: Offer a detailed sequence of steps for regular data backups as well as procedures for swift and effective data recovery in the event of unexpected loss and downtime.
• Network Configuration Changes: Ensure modifications are executed systematically and with minimal disruption to ongoing operations.
• Software Deployment: Guide teams through the deployment process, reducing the risk of errors and ensuring a standardized approach to implementation.
• Emergency Response: Serve as a critical tool for outlining precise steps to be taken, facilitating a swift and organized response to critical situations.
• User Access Management: Provide a clear set of instructions for tasks such as user provisioning, de-provisioning, and access modifications, ensuring security and compliance.

What are Playbooks?

A playbook is a comprehensive document that outlines how to execute a process while keeping the team’s overarching strategy in mind. This type of document provides a high-level overview of the team’s processes.

For instance, a playbook for project initiation could cover defining goals, setting timelines, allocating resources, and conducting team briefings. It provides a strategic overview, team roles, and an insight into the company’s project management methodology.

Playbooks often contain more contextual information than a runbook. This might cover the playbook’s goals, an organizational chart, and the company’s mission and vision statements. These guides also serve as a safety net in unforeseen circumstances. While playbooks may involve automation, they typically require a person to execute some or all of the steps.

When to Use Playbooks

Playbooks provide the bigger picture and are suited for the following scenarios:

• Product Launch: Guide teams through the strategic steps for a successful product launch, covering marketing plans, customer communication, and cross-functional collaboration.
• Disaster Recovery: Offer a structured approach for disaster recovery, including data restoration, system rebooting, and stakeholder communication to minimize downtime.
• Mergers and Acquisitions: Provide a comprehensive guide for integrating IT systems and aligning business processes during mergers and acquisitions.
• Customer Support: Help define procedures for efficiently handling complex customer support issues, ensuring consistent and effective escalation processes.
• Compliance Audits: Document procedures for compliance audits, data handling, and reporting to ensure standardized and controlled regulatory adherence.
• Technology Adoption: Serve as a phased guide for adopting new technologies, covering training, system integration, and troubleshooting for a smooth transition.
• Strategic IT Planning: Outline processes for strategic IT planning, including technology assessments, capacity planning, and resource allocation aligned with organizational goals.
• Crisis Communication: Define communication protocols during crises, ensuring timely and consistent information dissemination to mitigate reputational risks.

Choosing between a runbook and a playbook for documenting processes involves understanding key differences in their applicability. Both serve well in sharing organizational knowledge, facilitating skill development, and suggesting process enhancements without burdening senior team members.

Playbooks excel in documenting extensive processes, while runbooks shine when detailing specific tasks. By considering the scope of documentation, project or task handoff, and resource optimization, you can pinpoint whether a comprehensive playbook or a focused runbook is the optimal solution for your documentation needs.

In essence, playbooks and runbooks share more similarities than differences. Both demand thoughtful planning, delivering faster, consistent results that enhance overall efficiency. Whether as Word documents, Confluence pages, or wiki platforms, both runbooks and playbooks necessitate regular updates to stay aligned with evolving business and IT landscapes.

Conclusion

Runbooks and playbooks are both essential components of an operational team’s toolkit. Runbooks provide step-by-step instructions for specific tasks, ensuring consistent and efficient execution. Playbooks offer a broader perspective, outlining the strategic approach for complex processes. By understanding the core strengths of each, you can effectively document your organization’s procedures, promoting knowledge sharing, streamlining operations, and enabling faster incident resolution. Remember, both runbooks and playbooks require regular updates to reflect changes in your business and IT environment. Invest the time in creating and maintaining this documentation, and you’ll reap the rewards of a well-oiled operational machine.

Squadcast is an popular alternative to Pagerduty Incident Management tool that’s purpose-built for SRE. Get rid of unwanted alerts, receive relevant notifications and integrate with popular ChatOps tools. Work in collaboration using virtual incident war rooms and use automation to eliminate toil.